Back to Debates

LeftMax Baker-Hytch

VS

RightAlex O'Connor

The argument for God from Reason • Cosmic Skeptic vs Max Baker-Hytch

Philosophy (Ethics, Epistemology, Metaphysics)DuelAdded 7d ago

Alex O'Connor, known as Cosmic Skeptic, and Christian philosopher Max Baker-Hytch debate the argument for God from reason, a concept popularized by C.S. Lewis in his book *Miracles*. The central dispute revolves around whether our rational capabilities can be adequately explained within an atheist naturalist worldview. Baker-Hytch argues that the existence of reason points to a divine origin, suggesting that naturalism struggles to account for the human capacity for logic and understanding. O'Connor pushes back against this assertion, defending the coherence of an atheist naturalist perspective in explaining the emergence and function of reason without recourse to a supernatural explanation.

#Atheism #Apologetics #Philosophy Of Religion #Theism #Naturalism #Metaphysics #Reason #Epistemology #Cs Lewis

Log in to vote and see community results.

You can still watch the debate and read comments while logged out.

Related Debates

Keep exploring by speaker, topic, and category.

6 suggestions

Shared speakerReligion & TheologyDuel

Theism vs Atheism | Jonathan McLatchie vs Alex O’Connor

Jonathan McLatchievsAlex O'Connor

Shared speakerReligion & TheologyDuel

Alex O'Connor & Dr. Francis Collins Debate God's Existence

Alex O'ConnorvsDr. Francis Collins

6 shared topicsPhilosophy (Ethics, Epistemology, Metaphysics)Duel

DEBATE: Does Naturalism Explain Reality Better than Theism? | MadeByJimbob vs. Planet Peterson

MadeByJimbobvsPlanet Peterson

Shared speakerReligion & TheologyTeam

LIVE DEBATE: Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle vs Alex O'Connor and Phil Halper

Alex O'ConnorvsPhil HalpervsCliffe KnechtlevsStuart Knechtle

Shared speakerReligion & TheologyDuel

DEBATE: God's Existence - Alex O'Connor Vs. Trent Horn

Alex O'ConnorvsTrent Horn

Shared speakerPhilosophy (Ethics, Epistemology, Metaphysics)Duel

Alex O'Connor vs Cameron Bertuzzi • Why is there something rather than nothing?

Cameron BertuzzivsAlex O'Connor

Comments

Sort0 total

You must be logged in to comment. Log in

Loading comments…