Jordan Peterson and Sam Harris, the "is/ought problem"

Philosophy (Ethics, Epistemology, Metaphysics)DuelAdded 4d ago

Jordan Peterson and Sam Harris engage in a wide-ranging philosophical discussion, revisiting and expanding upon their previous debates. The central dispute revolves around the "is/ought problem," exploring how moral values (what "ought" to be) can be derived from factual observations (what "is"). They delve into the nature of consciousness, attention, and the role of evidence and logic in understanding reality. The conversation also explores the subjective experience of dreams, the impact of psychedelics on the self, and the practical application of meditative states, particularly in relation to Harris's "Waking Up" app. The discussion further extends to the complexities of organized religion, the interpretation of sacred texts, and the challenges posed by the postmodern predicament. Peterson and Harris examine the psychological and philosophical underpinnings of suffering, satisfaction, and discomfort, contrasting their perspectives on how individuals navigate everyday patterns and expectations. They also touch upon the ideas of Carl Rogers and the ecological approach to visual perception, integrating these concepts into their broader dialogue on human experience and the search for meaning.