Nigel Spivey Catharine Titi Alexander Herman Lord Sumption Mario Torretta Dominic Selwood

Should The Elgin Marbles Be Repatriated?

History & CivilizationTeamAdded 7d ago

This debate centers on the contentious issue of whether the Elgin Marbles, ancient Greek sculptures from the Parthenon currently housed in the British Museum, should be repatriated to Greece. Proponents of repatriation, including classicist Nigel Spivey, international lawyer Catharine Titi, and art law expert Alexander Herman, argue that the marbles were illegally removed by Lord Elgin in the 19th century and should be returned to their country of origin. They emphasize principles of cultural heritage law and the moral imperative of restitution. Conversely, opponents of repatriation, such as retired Supreme Court Justice Lord Sumption, classical archaeologist Mario Torretta, and historian Dominic Selwood, defend the British Museum's continued possession. They assert the legality of the marbles' acquisition and highlight the museum's role in their preservation and global accessibility. The discussion delves into historical claims, legal interpretations, and the broader implications for cultural property and international relations.

#Elgin Marbles #Parthenon Marbles #Repatriation #Cultural Heritage #British Museum #Ancient Greece #Art Law #International Law #History #Restitution

Speaker roster

Competitive voting and results are currently available for duel debates only. This team debate is fully viewable and commentable, and broader format support will follow later.

Nigel Spivey Catharine Titi Alexander Herman Lord Sumption Mario Torretta Dominic Selwood